
It’s Sunday morning, and my mind has wandered to this thing we call the cost of living crisis. There’s growing dissatisfaction in many Western societies, and while some people are clearly doing it tough, others appear to be doing rather well. Whenever I’m back in Australia, I see queues for $6.50 coffees, restaurants doing a roaring trade, expensive cars filling the roads and people walking dogs that probably cost more to maintain than a family in some parts of Asia. Yet in my hometown of Fremantle, there are people sleeping rough with their worldly possessions piled into shopping trolleys.
Of course, inequality is nothing new. Societies have always been divided between those who have plenty and those who have very little. What’s changed, I suspect, is how visible these divisions have become. Social media has given ordinary people a voice, allowing them to share their frustrations, hardships and grievances with an audience that previous generations could scarcely have imagined. And that’s a wonderful thing in many respects. But it has also made the differences between us rather difficult to ignore.
There are endless photographs of crayfish and caviar for Sunday lunch, expensive wines, balconies overlooking the Italian countryside and skiing holidays in Whistler, all posted for the world to see. And why not? People work hard, enjoy their success and naturally want to share their happiness with others. I certainly don’t begrudge them that. But occasionally I wonder how these images might appear to someone struggling to pay the rent or put food on the table. What one person shares as a happy moment might look rather like gloating to someone whose circumstances are very different. And I’m guilty of posting photographs of my own good fortune. Not that I have a fortune in the financial sense, but I certainly enjoy sharing the occasional happy moment, particularly when I’m travelling. So I’m hardly in a position to criticise. It’s the increasingly visible contrast between these different worlds that my mind has drifted towards today.
What is concerning me this morning is what happens when these differences become sources of resentment and division. People who feel cheated or forgotten naturally look for others who understand their frustrations. They gravitate towards groups that share their grievances and sometimes towards people promising simple solutions to complicated problems. Those who have plenty, meanwhile, have their own interests to protect. Before long, we’re building walls around ourselves, surrounding ourselves with people who think and feel much as we do, and becoming increasingly suspicious of those on the other side.
I suppose we’ve been doing this for centuries. Medieval societies had their castles, walls and moats to keep the wealthy and powerful safely separated from the peasants. I’m reminded of that wonderfully absurd scene in Monty Python and the Holy Grail where King Arthur encounters a peasant working in the mud who challenges his authority. It’s absurd, but there’s something rather familiar about it all. Today we may not have castles and moats, but we still seem rather good at building walls between ourselves. And social media, for all its wonderful capacity to connect us, may also be helping us build them, and divide us further. It has given a voice where voices were once silenced.
Having spent considerable time in the Pacific and across Asia, I’ve often been struck by the generosity of people who have relatively little. It sometimes makes me wonder whether our emphasis on independence and personal success has come at the expense of our sense of community. But I wouldn’t want to romanticise poorer societies or pretend that Australians aren’t generous. That would be an unfair generalisation, and generalising is something we should be careful about. It’s a short journey from generalisation to stereotyping, bias and prejudice, and sometimes something considerably uglier. Rather ironic, really, when I’m sitting here wondering about the divisions between us.
And I’m hardly in a position to lecture anyone. I’ve worked hard for what I have, and like most people, I’m rather protective of it. I even have security cameras, and when I travel, my five guitars are locked away in a special place. I’ve benefited from opportunities that others may never have enjoyed, yet I’m not always as willing to share what I have as perhaps I should be. I can recognise the contradictions without pretending that I’m somehow above them.
I don’t have any political or economic solutions, and I’m not convinced anyone has a simple answer to divisions that have existed for centuries. I just find myself wondering this morning whether making those divisions more visible, while increasingly retreating into our own groups, is taking us somewhere rather unpleasant.
And where, I wonder, is it all leading?
